Disputes

· 4 min read

The first ninety days

of a commercial lawsuit.

The preservation notice, the first response and the first scheduling order shape a case more than most clients expect.

A printed contract with red-pen edits on a pale oak desk, with reading glasses and a cup of coffee

Clients tend to picture a lawsuit as a trial at the end. In practice most commercial cases are shaped in the first three months, when deadlines are short, the facts are still fresh and the other side has not yet settled on its story. What follows is a general outline of those ninety days. Courts and judges differ, so treat the timing as an example, not a promise.

Week one: stop documents from disappearing

The first task is not a filing. It is a written instruction to preserve. Once a lawsuit is reasonably foreseeable, a company must keep anything that may be relevant: email, chat messages, shared drives, text messages, calendar entries and the paper files in someone’s drawer. Automatic deletion has to be switched off, and the laptops of departing employees should not be wiped.

A short list of the people most likely to hold relevant material, usually five to ten of them, is enough to start. It can grow. What cannot be repaired later is a gap that opens in the first week and a judge who learns about it in month six.

Weeks one to four: the first response

A defendant has limited time to respond after being served. In federal court the usual period to answer or move to dismiss is 21 days after service, and in Illinois state court an appearance is generally due within 30 days. Parties often agree to extensions and judges often grant them once, so confirm the deadline on the day the papers arrive rather than the day before they are due.

The response is a choice between two paths. An answer admits or denies each allegation and may add affirmative defenses. A motion to dismiss argues that the complaint fails as a matter of law even if every fact in it is true. A motion is worth bringing when it is likely to narrow the case, and worth skipping when it would only delay the case and irritate the judge.

“Few cases are won in the first ninety days. A good many are lost there.”

Weeks four to eight: the first conference

Early in the case the judge will usually hold a conference to set a schedule. In federal court the lawyers are first expected to meet and discuss the case, including the scope of discovery, how electronic documents will be handled and whether the dispute might settle. Decisions made at that meeting come back later, so it is worth arriving with a position on each of these:

  • Which custodians and date ranges are reasonable, and which requests are too broad.

  • In what format documents will be exchanged.

  • How privileged material will be logged, and whether a protective order is needed for confidential business information.

  • Whether an early mediation would help.

The scheduling order that follows sets dates for discovery, expert disclosures and motions. Those dates are rarely moved by much, so a realistic schedule is a gift to your own team.

Weeks eight to thirteen: the first exchange

Initial disclosures and the first written discovery requests arrive in this period. Each side learns what the other considers important. It is also the first moment at which a client can reasonably price the case: how much discovery is likely to cost, which facts are strongest and weakest, and what a settlement might look like.

Many clients want to talk settlement at this point, and some should. The conversation is easier once you have reviewed your own documents and know what the other side is likely to find in them. Settling before you know your weaknesses usually means settling for less.

What a client can do

  • Send the preservation instruction on day one and confirm in writing that it was followed.

  • Name one person at the company to coordinate with counsel.

  • Keep discussion of the dispute out of email and chat unless a lawyer is copied.

  • Ask for a budget by phase, and for an update whenever its assumptions change.

None of this is dramatic, and that is the point. A well-run first ninety days leaves a case in a position where its facts, not its procedure, decide the outcome.

Margaret Ellery, Founding Partner

Margaret Ellery

Margaret Ellery

Founding Partner ·

Founding Partner ·

Trials & Disputes

Trials & Disputes

Tried 34 cases to verdict, first as a federal prosecutor in Chicago and then for companies on both sides of the v.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.