Investigations

· 4 min read

When a subpoena arrives:

the first twenty-four hours.

What to preserve, who should speak and why scope is often negotiable when a government subpoena lands on your desk.

A printed contract with red-pen edits on a pale oak desk, with reading glasses and a cup of coffee

A subpoena from a grand jury, a regulator or a prosecutor does not mean that the company has done something wrong. It does mean that someone has decided your records may matter. How the company behaves in the first day is noticed, and it is the part of the process that is entirely in your hands.

The first hour: understand what you have

Work out what kind of document it is. A grand jury subpoena, an SEC subpoena, a civil investigative demand and a search warrant each carry different rules and deadlines. Note the date it was served, who served it, the return date and the agency or office behind it. Then call counsel. Do not set it aside to deal with later, and do not begin collecting documents on your own.

Preserve everything

Switch off automatic deletion for email, chat and messaging tools, and suspend the routine recycling of laptops and phones. Include personal devices if business is conducted on them. Tell the people most likely to hold relevant material, in writing, to keep everything. The rule that matters most is that nothing should be deleted, altered or tidied up, however innocent the reason. Destroying records after learning of an investigation can create a far bigger problem than anything in the records.

“The documents are rarely the real danger. What happens to them in the first week often is.”

Control the conversation

Agents sometimes contact employees directly, at work or at home. Employees are free to speak with them or to decline, and they are entitled to have a lawyer present. The company can tell employees these things and can offer them counsel. It should not tell them to refuse to cooperate or to say anything in particular, because that can itself be treated as obstruction.

Designate one person to receive all contact from the agency and to route it to counsel. Everyone else should be told that they may be contacted and who to call.

Scope is often negotiable

A subpoena is frequently broader than what the investigators actually need. Counsel can usually speak with the lawyer who issued it to narrow the request, agree a rolling production, limit date ranges and custodians, and settle search terms. Those conversations are easier and more productive the earlier they begin.

Separate counsel for individuals

The interests of the company and of individual executives and employees can diverge. Consider early whether any individual should have their own lawyer, and who should pay. A single lawyer representing everyone is convenient until it is not.

Do and don’t

  • Do call counsel before anyone replies to the agency.

  • Do suspend deletion of email, chat and phone data.

  • Do keep a log of who received the subpoena and what was done in response.

  • Don’t discuss the matter with the employees it may concern.

  • Don’t produce documents before the scope is negotiated and privileged material is reviewed.

Marcus Leland, Partner

Marcus Leland

Marcus Leland

Partner ·

Partner ·

Investigations

Investigations

Eleven years as an Assistant U.S. Attorney. Now represents companies and executives in grand jury, SEC and DOJ matters.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.