Most workplace complaints are resolved in a conversation. A few are not, and when an allegation is serious, concerns a senior person or may end in a claim, the way the company investigates it becomes evidence in its own right. A careless investigation can cost more than the conduct it was meant to examine. These are the points that most often decide whether one holds up.
Decide who investigates
The investigator should be impartial and able to be seen as impartial. An HR manager is often the right choice for a routine matter. If the complaint involves a senior executive, HR itself, or the person who would normally decide the outcome, bring in someone from outside the reporting line, either another trained employee or an outside lawyer or investigator.
Write down the scope
Before the first interview, record what is being investigated: the specific allegations, the period they cover and the policies they may engage. Scope can change as facts emerge, but it should change in writing. Consider interim measures that protect everyone without punishing anyone, such as changing reporting lines or schedules while the work is done.
Interview consistently
Speak to the person who complained first, then the witnesses, and the person complained about last, so that they can respond to everything. Prepare the same core questions for each witness, take careful notes, and ask for documents rather than relying on memory. Do not promise absolute confidentiality, which no investigator can keep. Promise that information will be shared only as far as the process needs.
“An investigation is only as credible as its notes.”
Decide about privilege at the start
If the company wants legal advice from the investigation, it should be directed by a lawyer from the start and the engagement should say so. Be aware of the trade-off. If the company later relies on the investigation to defend itself, for example to show it responded promptly and fairly, it may be treated as waiving privilege over the work it relied on. Settle the approach before the work begins, not after it ends.
Make findings you can explain
Most employers use the “more likely than not” standard. Findings should separate what happened from whether it broke a policy and from whether it breaks the law, and should explain how credibility was weighed when accounts differ. A short, clear report is more useful than a long one that no one finishes reading.
Close the loop
Tell the person who complained and the person complained about the outcome, to the extent appropriate for each.
Apply any discipline consistently with how similar conduct has been handled before.
Check in with the person who complained after thirty and ninety days to confirm there has been no retaliation.
Keep the file in one place with restricted access, and decide how long it will be kept.

Executive agreements, restrictive covenants and workplace investigations. Former in-house counsel at a national retailer.




